I think they are pushing a spell shaman archetype that’s why

Kinda disappointed wanted mage’s studies to discover a spell but the card is still pretty good. Suddenly the trash legendaries for mage this xpac seems a bit more playable. This card is 4 stars.

Very overrated for mage. It’s 4 mana and the minions already gotta be on the board. Kinda hard to pull of since mages minions are kinda expensive you could run cheap minions with a burn/token/spell generation kinda archetype but that just doesen’t work in plat-diamond-legend. Overall 3/5 stars for mage and 4/5 stars for rouge maybe even 5 since Rouge can pull of these crazy combos and 1 cost minions is extremely powerful in Rouge. This is kinda a much worse version of pocket galaxy (kinda)

6 stars beyond powerful this is just ridicilous..

1/4 weapon*

Very nice. Love the card design. Pretty good a 1 mana 1/4 is good in itself and the effect is pretty strong. Can force death rattles and make very interesting plays. 5/5 stars nothing to lose and a very useful weapon for it’s cost.

Good point just seems way too slow I hope that I’m wrong tho.

Eccentric Scribe and TOTEM GOLIATH are two completely different cards. This card is 1 mana cheaper gets you 4 different minions not 4 1/1 but a 1/1 and three 0/2 with different effects. Also the overload can be utilized in shaman with a variety of different cards you now also have lightning bloom which can cheat out multiple cards. Therefore I think this card is at least 3.5 stars and it will see some play. Sure not a game breaking card but still not trash either. Just seems like you really hate death rattle cards.

Yeah u can basically win with t4 decks against t1 if u top deck everything but what are the chances? 5%?

4/5? Wtf? How could it be 5 for you? 1 mana kill the entire board?

Oh boy were you wrong…

Buff them in totem shaman*

Dude it summons 4 tokens on a 4/5 body for a total of 5 mana. How is this “2.5” stars? You could buff the totem shaman or bloodlust them. Also you know exactly what you will be getting so that makes it possible to plan ahead how to use the totems to the fullest. Definitely not 2.5 stars! And yes you can silence it but it’s still a dangerous card. You could use your argument to argue that every single death rattle card is bad because of silence which is definitely not the case.

Oh no not more warrior board clears…

Wow! Really nice legendary. 5 stars!

Nope. Then it would have been “discover a spell from your deck or choose a spell from your deck” it’s random

Trash spell. Probably meant to make the mage spell card pool worse. Ok for rouge

Not really good cause it casts the spell and doesen’t copy it. 3.5 stars could have been a really solid card if it copied the spell instead.

Than*

Slightly worse then siamat. 3.5-4 stars