Nightfall's Comments
Cowbell Soloist
I remember a (now) legacy card that did the same for 5 mana, but without the restriction. It never saw play. Is a card, that was unplayable from the start of the game, playable for 2 mana less BUT with a restriction? NO
1/5
Pozzik, Audio Engineer
I like this, actually. I’m gonna make a bold prediction and say this will see play! Nobody wants to play a 3/3, even more so if they’re facing an aggro deck. If you’re playing an aggro deck that cares for the board, a sticky but aggressively statted minion like this could really help.
4/5
Pyrotechnician
4 mana is just too much of an upfront cost to generate some spells. Unless the Fire Spell pool is small enough and there is some broken Fire Spell that you can generate multiple times, it’s gonna be garbage
1/5
Merch Seller
The dream scenario is locking your opponent out by filling the top of their deck with garbage spells.
The reality is that you’re just gonna be giving your opponent a random spell, while playing a poorly statted minion.
1/5
Candleraiser
If it hits that finale and manages to give 2 other minions divine shield, it’s actually really good. That said, that is a miracle situation, and you’re more likely to hit just 1 minion, or not be able to trigger the Finale.
3.5/5, has potential
Cover Artist
I don’t know what I should want to copy with this card… Faceless Corruptor has been around for forever, and this is only 1 mana cheaper. Faceless saw no play outside of meme decks, so I ought to score this one low.
1/5, maybe the average rating of ~4 means I’m missing something, but I’m not seeing it.
Tony, King of Piracy
This card is going to be fun to mess around with!
On the competitive side though, it has a crazy effect and a fair body. Pair that with the Finale, and you actually have a card that could see play. It also has the potential to break things, but I don’t see it. Maybe in a Warlock Jailer deck with Mal’Ganis and Tony, but that seems closer to meme still than competitive.
Fun: 5/5
Competitive: 3/5
Ghost Writer
The Finale is going to be tough to hit most of the time, and it is really just worse than Nerubian Vizier. I can’t imagine this seeing much play, but I guess I’ll give it a slight bump because it does have a lot of value for a single card, that is, if you can hit the Finale.
2/5
Unpopular Has-Been
I just can’t think of any deck that would maybe wanna play this…
1/5
The One-Amalgam Band
I am not sure if an amalgam deck is going to be competitive. If it isn’t, it’s in spite of this card.
4/5
Concert Promo-Drake
It’s a dragon.
It’s Tradeable.
The Finale is easy to trigger (paired with Hero Power).
Might see play as the 30th card in a deck somewhere.
3/5
Mish-Mash Mosher
Reminds me of Batterhead. I can’t remember that card getting any play, so…
1/5
Deathbringer Saurfang
Yo this card is not that bad. Sure, the initial cost of 5 mana is very bad, but after that it’s basically free. you pay 5 health, but it also saves 5 health, OR MORE if they can’t deal the neat 5 damage, AND they take 3 damage in return when they destroy this minion instead of 0 when they attack face to deal essentially the same amount of damage.
Soulstealer
Twisting nether, but you get corpses AND a 5/5, really puts into perspective how bad twisting is in today’s hearthstone
5/5
Alexandros Mograine
Expensive for a non-immediate effect, but that is one hell of an effect. I don’t see how any other control deck would outlast this…
5/5 against control, but pretty bad against other decks…
Dark Transformation
It does work with the hero power, as such it’s much more consistant than other kinds of transform cards.
3.5/5
Solid discover minion. Perhaps something like Blood Death knight would like to discover some of those great legendaries! Okay, convinced myself…
4/5