OP, beast tag, infinite value, and a lot of support (0 mana dredge AND draw!) disgusting if you don’t like druids… 4/5. Thank god Arbor Up! rotates soon…

Broken in Mech Mage decks, if they add Zylliax to Core Set think about it… They give a lot of support this expansion so this card will see play. 4/5.

Naga Mage is a thing with this card! Wow, is bit conditional but the whole new spells/nagas package feels really solid in this new “Value” deck, this card is an enabler. 4/5.

This card was VERY unfair, for 5 mana you get on an empty board 8/6 stats! but over 5 1/1 tokens you add +10 dmg on turn 5 and a board state very hard to deal.

I’m not sure of this, because you need cards in hand AND murlocs on board at the same time! and also pay 2 mana for the buff… This is really hard to evaluate but on average you give +2/+2 or +3/+3 to 2 or 3 murlocs on hand, maybe good enough idk. 3/5.

Insane value even if played on a tiny mech, I guess Core Set 2022 will add a bunch of mechs if not only Mage and Paly will play her. 4/5.

I don’t get the point of this card; you add a card to your opponent’s hand to burn next draw? Shadow tag coudl help for a Tamsin’s madness

Solid tech card, that will see a lot of play if “buff/DR/end of turn” comes around. 4/5.

This card is very bad, isn’t it? Change my mind. 1/5.

Damm! I was also considering the new murloc diver as a good target for this!

Not many good outcast payoff cards for the moment (core set maybe..) but auto-include if this archetype exists. 2/5.

A cool combo: cast it over a Venomous Scorpid for a full board clear! (unless it get silenced)

This counts effective mana spent or the real cost (before mana cheat)?? This is important because there are big spells that gets discounts so can cheat this giant soon!! Want to see this interaction tbh. This is a good Switheroo target in a Naga Priest deck too!

This card is nuts! Play it over a babbling book on curve and trade! I love this card, so cheap (but conditional).

WoW this is a force of the Nature, maybe a burn finisher and Elemental tag! Only 3 mana! WTF!? 5/5.

2 mana draw 5! ok let’ssay in average draw 2 or 3! for 2-mana is very efficient, so now let’s see the Core set and the other cards of Sunken City!

Hold on 2 weeks more! Guff will dodge the nerfs for the moment!

I’m not sure; Relics are a bit slow and clunky. Ring of Tides, can cast a second Rune for 1 mana, the weapon feels a bit slow, the horn could be a thing (4-mana random Colossal) and the Tidestone is nice value but slow again.
Anyway Naga Mage/Priest/Druid will pop-up for sure and this payoff card is an auto-include so if Nagas are meta this will see play. 4/5.

Ok, this can go face for 8 dmg but I’m not sure if 9 hp is enough to deal with 2 large minions before die. Control Warrior already has a win con (Kaza) and this beast can’t fit in it (let’s see). 2/5.

5 mana seems a bit slow for Rogue, but I see a nice combo after casting 2 copies of this you can play Mr Smite + Sr Finley (in this order) to get 6 + 4 x 3 DMG = 18 (not lethal of course) in turn 7/8 could be enough to close a game, who knows..